This is the first part of my Fellowship-only rollout of Tolkien’s Tragedy: Concerning Númenor, The Rings of Power, and the Second Age. I welcome any and all feedback, questions, corrections, etc. In other words, be a part of this books’ journey to publication! Annon allen - THANK YOU!!!
Table of Contents
Introduction: Númenor & The Mind of Tolkien
Introduction: Númenor & The Mind of Tolkien
At the center of the Middle-earth legendarium stands Númenor.
Númenor: raised out of the Great Sea, halfway between the undying lands of Aman and the mortal shores of the Grey Havens.
Númenor: whose history forms the heart of the Second Age.
Númenor: the last great pillar of the legendarium to be conceived by Tolkien, and an irreplaceable connection between the otherwise disparate First and Third Ages.
To understand Númenor is to unlock the greatest mysteries of Tolkien’s subcreation.
And yet, for all of its importance and centrality, we know so little about Númenor, and have so little to go on in terms of Tolkien’s writings about it.
In the Fall of 2022, most of Tolkien’s writings on the topic were collected by Brian Sibley in a single volume titled The Fall Of Númenor. As wonderful as this collection is, and as invaluable as Sibley’s efforts are in unifying the disparate texts concerning Númenor and the Second Age, there yet remains an inherently fragmented and seemingly incomplete picture of this vast and important era in the history of Middle-earth.1 Of course, this is due entirely to the fact that Tolkien himself wrote so much about it, but neither completed nor published most of it during his lifetime.
The largest portions that we have on the subject of Númenor come from two key works: “Akallabêth” and “Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age”, both of which were originally published as part of The Silmarillion in 1977. However, even these works are merely historical overviews, and while they give us much to consider, they roughly equate to about one page per 200 years of history.2
Indeed, though the tragedy I have in mind with the title of this book is the very history of Númenor and its downfall, the greater tragedy is perhaps that we will never have a story *about* Númenor on the scale of The Lord of the Rings from Tolkien’s own words, or even on the scale of “Beren and Lúthien”, one of the great tales of the First Age.
Nevertheless, the writings Tolkien did leave us concerning Númenor and the Second Age tell us a great deal about it explicitly, and thanks in large part to Tolkien’s style, lush with the fruits of a truly poetic mind, those writings hint at much, much more. Indeed, even with texts as sparse as The Line of Elros or The Tale of Years, I believe much can be inferred through a process of textual interrogation.
While I, as a self-proclaimed Tolkienite, wince at the glorious possibilities that we all have missed out on, it occurs to me that we have only just begun to understand what Tolkien DID tell us about Númenor, and there is much to explore about it, both in terms of the legendarium and canon of Tolkien’s direct composition, as well as in its textual history and development in relation to The Lord of The Rings and The Silmarillion.
Therefore, the purpose of this book is to more deeply explore the Númenorean legend as we have received it from Tolkien himself and to unpack and extrapolate from this as much as we can concerning his intent for the legend. After all, why would he have concocted a detailed outline for a history of almost 3,500 years and not expect us to wonder at all of the matters that lay between the lines?
Indeed, why allude to curiosities for no reason? As we explore these works, we traverse the vast landscape of Tolkien’s mind and imagination, which gave us The Lord of the Rings itself. And it was this very mind that seemed to compose in this interrogatory fashion. As an example, Tolkien once quipped that he was surprised to discover Strider at the Prancing Pony, and that the Ents were an altogether unexpected discovery.3 Tolkien regarded himself as this sort of writer - discovering new realities as he wrote, almost as if they already and really existed. That is one of the very joys that draws many readers into his works: this notion of a vast reality that goes beyond the facts and events traced by the narrative itself. It’s as if Tolkien is as astonished as we are to find this vast and wonderful world unfolding before us.
To be sure, Tolkien might have left us much more, had his lifespan been that of the early Númenorean kings and queens. Unfortunately, it was not, and so we are left as fans to ponder what has been handed down to us.
The Amazon TV Show
Another important factor that has driven me to write this book is Amazon’s TV show The Rings of Power, which depicts some parts of the Second Age. For many Tolkien fans, including myself,
this show has left much to be desired, especially concerning its vision of Númenor and its compression of the Second Age timeline found in The Lord of the Rings. For others, it is a welcome addition to the catalog of Middle-earth screen adaptations.
While I do not spend the major portion of this book on any sort of critical analysis of The Rings of Power, the show’s status as the most expensive production in TV history and as a close relative to one of the most successful franchises in cinematic history nevertheless puts Númenor and the stories of the Second Age higher in the consciousness of popular culture.
Given this, I believe it raises the key question of Tolkien’s intent for Númenor. What DID Tolkien really intend Númenor to be like? Furthermore, what were the key themes that undergirded the Second Age of Middle-earth, in which the greater story of Númenor is situated?
These questions are of great importance for understanding the allure and power of The Lord of the Rings as a work of literature. Why does it have such a deep impact on so many? Why do I and others consider it to be a life-changing work, even the greatest novel of the 20th century? These questions should matter to anyone hoping to adapt it to another medium, for they get to the heart of Tolkien’s genius, and the answers inform how such adaptations are executed and achieved, and even whether they will find success on the artistic level.4
Does It Really Matter What Tolkien Thought?
Still, some have asked: Does it really matter what Tolkien thought? And even if it does, how can we actually know?
One of the trickiest questions when it comes to understanding Tolkien’s works is the question of authorial intent. What did he mean by his works? When he leaves large gaps in the story, or gives curious details regarding a Númenorean ruler whom we know little else about, does he intend for us to be able to infer from that some larger point? The problem is that Tolkien was prone to being rather elf-like in such matters, in the way that Frodo teases the elf Gildor: “Go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes.”5 I don’t fault Tolkien for this. In fact, I think it’s better when an author of fiction doesn’t write with some great point or hidden agenda in mind.
Tolkien wrote primarily for the story itself. He wasn’t the type to write moralistically or allegorically, and he was clear about his disdain for certain forms of storytelling that do so. When pressed by one fan as to whether Orcs were Communists, Tolkien responded: “To ask if Orcs ‘are’ Communists is to me as sensible as asking if Communists are Orcs.”6 The point seems to be that Tolkien intends to abjure all notions of “hard symbolism” from his storytelling.
But the paradox of his perspective is nowhere better glimpsed than in his well-known comment to the Jesuit priest Fr. Robert Murray. Having been asked by Murray about the role of his Catholic faith in writing The Lord of the Rings, Tolkien responded:
The Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision.7
In other words, Tolkien did not set out to write a “Catholic fantasy novel” or something like that. However, he’s not actually saying “both no and yes” here. As he was writing, his own concerns and philosophical background worked their way into the novel in organic fashion, so that as he revised the draft, he was able to see the traces and hints that his deep religious faith played in composing the work.
Of course, this shouldn’t surprise us one bit. It’s exactly what authors do: the sum of who they are, their life experiences and philosophical outlook, are bound to manifest in various ways within the stories they tell. It’s only natural. In fact, if they somehow tried to AVOID speaking of certain things, it would likely make the work seem inauthentic, even fraudulent or fragmented.
I would say that Tolkien wrote PRIMARILY for the sake of the story itself - not to impress some underlying symbolism on the reader, but to tell a story that would ENCHANT the reader into feeling as though they were glimpsing another reality. In fact, this was what he claimed all good fairy-stories do in his literary manifesto, On Fairy-stories, written just before he began to compose “The New Hobbit”, which would later become The Lord of the Rings.
However, in dealing with the fictional characters and situations of his story, any author is bound to put in their own perspective and philosophical outlook. Even if they are writing about some OTHER philosophical outlook which they do not hold to, they still write with their own perspective.
And in the story of Númenor, we have a particularly interesting situation, for the legend of Númenor began as something totally separate from The Hobbit’s nascent sequel: Tolkien’s unrealized time-travel taleThe Lost Road.8 It was only after its initial creation in the context of that story that Tolkien began to fold the legend of Númenor into The Lord of the Rings.9
The legend of Númenor and the Second Age of Middle-earth developed in parallel with The Lord of the Rings until they became different aspects of the same thing. And the fictional histories of both continued to develop even after the publication of Tolkien’s masterpiece. Tolkien was this kind of writer. For him, Middle-earth was a very real thing, and he seems to have felt almost duty-bound to explore it and articulate various realities about it. From this, we get most of the writings about Númenor that were published after his death. Tolkien, in a way, would go back and CONSCIOUSLY draw out the things he had UNCONSCIOUSLY hidden in the text.10
In sum, I am proposing that WE, Tolkien’s readers, have the opportunity to discern greater truths and insights within the skeletal structure of Númenor’s history and the other events of the Second Age, just as Tolkien did as he reflected on the first draft of The Lord of the Rings, and found it to be unintentionally “religious and Catholic.”
The Structure of This Book
I believe the best way to grasp and dive into the story of Númenor is chronologically, and so that’s how this book shall proceed.
However, it is important to grasp several key concepts at the outset. Therefore, the first two chapters will explore and expound Tolkien’s explicit thoughts on the Second Age as well as the salient ideas and themes that I find in the various texts and tales of Númenor and the Second Age.
From there, the next three chapters will examine the three millennia of Númenor’s existence, using major events, most especially the reigns of its various Kings and Queens, as markers upon the journey.
In conclusion, we will consider the climax of Númenor’s history: the tragedy of its Downfall, and the birth of the exilic realms Arnor and Gondor, and their continued struggle against Sauron.
Finally, I have reserved for the Appendices several matters which I believe will be of great interest to the reader.
In Appendix A, I will provide a complete list of writings directly pertaining to the Second Age of Middle-earth, as well as their sources, and a few brief thoughts on each.
In Appendix B, I will provide an outline for how I believe the story of the Second Age could have been successfully adapted as a TV show.
In Appendix C, I will consider future possibilities for storytelling in the legendarium of Middle-earth.
Finally, in Appendix D, we will consider The White Tree of Númenor, its symbolism, and the role of its progeny in the history of Gondor.
As part of the process of sifting through the annals of Númenor, I will explore the names of each of its rulers. With Tolkien - and perhaps in keeping with the way things were done by most ancient peoples - words, and especially names, matter greatly. So it behooves us to pay close attention to what various characters are named, because therein we will perhaps discover key insights and connections.
And now, without further ado, let us step foot into Middle-earth’s Second Age!
I will be continuing to roll out the chapters and appendices of Tolkien’s Tragedy over the next several weeks. Get notified when new chapters are released by signing up for this blog!
Next up: Chapter 1 - The Scope of the Second Age.
This is no fault of Sibley or the book, simply a statement of what the book’s intent was. The volume resides on my bookshelf, and I highly recommend it for those reading this book. In fact, I did a 38-part chapter-by-chapter video and podcast series on the book when it was first released. You can view that here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqUat2OcwnPDhZYIPn4Hmk54Q34CUaJtK
Imagine if future civilizations had even 1 page of documentation per year of American history, for example. So much would be lost! They would barely understand anything of what this highly significant culture was for the history of humanity!
Hammond, Wayne G., and Christina Scull. The Lord of the Rings: A Reader’s Companion (HarperCollinsPublishers, 2005), 155.
In the Appendices, I provide my own outline and notes for how I would have drawn up a TV show based on the stories of The Second Age. Furthermore, as I feel it is warranted, I will provide comparisons of the text and the TV show in footnotes throughout this book.
Tolkien, J.R.R. The Fellowship of the Ring, 2nd ed. (London: HarperCollinsPublishers, 2005), 105.
Tolkien, J.R.R. The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, ed. Humphrey Carpenter with Christopher Tolkien (Houghton Mifflin, 2000), 262.
Ibid., 172.
For my thoughts on The Lost Road, see the Appendices.
Something similar happened with The Hobbit. It began as something altogether separate from his Silmarillion tales, but with the inclusion of Elrond, was enfolded into the legendarium.
Therefore it’s not necessarily right to see these things as mere add-ons, but natural developments and clarifications. If we call them add-ons, we might as well say the same thing about The Hobbit or The Lord of the Rings itself!



Fantastic news John!! Love the introduction for your newest literary undertaking. I’m a little late to things and still working through the Silmarillion (left unread since my parents gifted me with a copy in 1977) — with much needed support from your unrivaled podcast. Could not be more excited for your continued guidance and wisdom across the critical Second Age. Very best on this latest contribution to the legendarium!!
Well done, John. I am very much looking forward to your keen insights in the chapters ahead!